Please watch that.
Here are my thoughts:
- I have never occupied anything I wasn’t supposed to. I believe it would be interesting to occupy something – a university is probably the best place to do that – but for a good cause. Their list of demands is pretty odd… Why the obsession over Gaza/Palestine? Would this have happened last year if Gaza hadn’t been bombed to bits? What about Darfur – wasn’t that all the rage a few years ago? Before that – it was Apartheid… How fickle we can be?
- The video above is pretty interesting. Not only does it show that the students are unorganized and delusional, it shows the university officials in a very good light. The camera man instigates the security officers (who look really bored) and practically begs them to abuse him and his party. Meanwhile, the University spokesperson just wants them to shut up so he can tell them they are probably not going to graduate from NYU. They are poised and let the students congregate… that request from the videographer for the guards to use “Earmuffs” was pretty ridiculous.
- Facilitate a meeting!? What? Are you high? There is nothing to facilitate. The University demanded your id cards – so they know who to expel/arrest, and another thing, your negotiators are pretty much never coming back. I’m sure NYU, much like the USA, does not negotiate with terrorists.
- There was no brutality. Even when that girl was pulled off the balcony – she was not in danger… she was just loud. When the camera moved over and she was standing there screaming. One quickly finds that she was merely pulled off the balcony by her shoulders. It’s NYU’s right. These students have trespassed on school property. From my understanding, the University does not allow students to be on that balcony in the winter (obviously since it’s cold and probably has no winter maintenance). So, the students had to break that door down. Property damage AND civil disobedience along with trespassing? Yikes…
- Shouldn’t the seniors know better than to cause the University to kick them out? They have spent 7 semesters here! Not to get a diploma would totally piss mommy and daddy off. Sure, it could be argued (in certain circles) that this was a good cause, but couldn’t there really have been a better way. The school totally let them keep those barriers up for one night – and then decided they were tired of that noise and kicked some ass. Start a petition, rally around the school frequently, make websites posting terrible Financial Aid packages – you can’t just take over a building!
- They seriously believe that the University (much like the KGB) was going to arrest them, ship them to Siberia and steal their things (because they are tired of drinking corporate water). Chances are if the University did anything terribly stupid, they would have a lawsuit. A macbook is hardly worth thousands of dollars in litigation with the owner. It makes no sense.
- Noam Chomsky wrote them a fucking letter of support! Good ol’ Noam. For some reason, I always think he’s deceased, but periodically, he does something that says, “Nope, still kicking!”, and I breathe a sigh of relief. This is the most recent thing I’ve heard from him.
I rarely side with the big guy – but this was straight up stupid. It always bugs me when people do something dumb and then claim its their legal right under the first amendment. Sure, you can scream whatever you want on the streets, but you can’t break into my house and yell at me about it. These kids deserve to be expelled for disrupting the lives of all the other students. Of all the 50,000 only 1,048 people (not necessarily students) have signed their petition on www.takebacknyu.com. That’s about 2% of the entire student population. I bet those kids will be telling this story for ages – while it just becomes an obscure footnote in NYU history.